Gary's Auto Repair Service, Inc.

Jan 30, 2025

Gary and Dave are awesome. They work very hard and try their best to give you a fair price and an excellent solution to the problem. I am so lucky to have found great mechanics and don't have to worry about getting about getting multiple quotes.

Jan 23, 2025

After an unfortunate incident having the motor in my wife’s Hyundai Sonata breaking down, I searched the area for a qualified local mechanics shop. Being still relatively new to area, I chose Gary’s based on several thoughtful positive reviews. Speaking to Gary briefly I told him the symptoms and he knew immediately the issue with the car - with the exception I thought the car had a different motor than what’s actually in the car. Gary also pointed me to Advance Tow to get my vehicle to his shop. Within an hour Gary rang me up telling me both good and bad news. Bad news the motor is blown and needs replacement. Good news there is a class action lawsuit and recall with Hyundai and the 2.4 L motor has a lifetime warranty. Both Gary and Dave got on the phone with me to tell me what they know. I then made arrangements for Advanced to bring the vehicle to the dealer. I really appreciate Gary and Dave’s fast action and getting me on the path to a resolution. I literally had no idea. Would recommend these very knowledgeable guys to anyone. So if you’re reading this review in a similar position no knowing where to take your vehicle to solve a problem - these guys are legit! Thank you again gentlemen !! 💪 Wanted to add that I've used Gary's since for several additional repairs on our 12 year old Hyundai. They have always solved the problems, at a reasonable cost and our car is doing great.

Jan 16, 2025

Always straight up with you regarding your vehicle. I have used him for 11 years and my partner has been using him for almost 20 years. I trust this guy. He is salt of the earth.

Nov 06, 2024

Super

Nov 06, 2024

Tesla , Porsche , Mercedes-Benz , Land Rover , BMW , Maserati

Nov 06, 2024

جيد جدا

Oct 06, 2024

Gary's a great guy thats been taking care for my moms car(s) for years, I brought my car there and he figured out what was wrong and fixed it.

Sep 06, 2024

1. Alignment is $250 yet every shop in Florida is about half. I called 2 shops who agreed this is way overpriced. 2. I was offered a "wholesale" tire price and with mount/balance was $140 per tire. I bought the same exact tires ($70 each) and had them mounted/ balanced for $91 each, about $50 less per tire and paid $21 not $40 for mount/balance. 3. My rear brake pads are "metal to metal" I was told, and need new brakes, although I went home, took the wheel off to inspect them and have 50% of pad material left. My regular mechanic was shown this and was in disbelief that I was lied to I checked every part he suggested which were grossly marked up. Argue with me but these are the facts

Jun 06, 2024

Came in with no appointment, they prioritize my vehicle, and it was finished in less than 24 hours.fixed my air and did diagnostic test 👍🏼

Feb 06, 2024

I can not say enough about these guys! I was told by a very reputable shop that my car wasn't worth working on and I should buy another! I knew that wasn't the case and got my car to Gary's! The other guys had had the car for a month and couldn't get it to run properly! They had it diagnosed and fixed within a day! Hmmm... These guys just took a minute and actually looked at the car! I will be a very loyal patron and will be recommending to anyone I know!

Feb 06, 2024

I’d have to pull up my invoices. I think my wheel bearings needed to be replaced. And I’ve been buying. My batteries from Gary for years. He is very knowledgeable, and unlike some mechanics comes out and explains everything. I know that the few problems I’ve had Gary has taken care of right away, sonObhighly recommend him. There’s nothing like a stop engine warning on your way to or from work! I usually wait in the waiting room with his wife Michelle and dog Summer Gary , his family and crew is my first go to repair shop if my suv needs service.

Feb 06, 2024

Mad people, don't go there, crabby Dave. ,

Feb 06, 2024

My car runs like new now!

Feb 06, 2024

Went to several auto repair shops trying to resolve a couple problems with broken passenger door lock/latch operation and difficulty with starter. Got the run around or promises of getting to it in a few weeks. Took it to Garys on same day i called them. They jumped on it right away and fixed the problems promptly. I will use them again. Very efficient operation.

Feb 06, 2024

Would not take my vehicles anywhere else. Expert work Always. Gary and Dave can fix anything!

Feb 06, 2023

First time here. I can tell that Gary and Dave know their mechanical stuff. They also work on diesels.

Feb 06, 2023

Great guys. Very knowledgeable and great prices. Highly recommend

Feb 06, 2023

I called to ask about putting doors onto mu car I have in my possession just needed someone with mechanic history to help me put them on, well when he answered(Gary)he wasn't very pleasant, and as I described my issue he says in a voice and manner like I wasted his time asking, he did tell me I need an auto body shop, but said in a way like I was annoying, not in a cheerful tone most people have at a place of business, u know, 'glad to help', unfortunately I had to rate him so he can see that maybe he shouldn't be handling the phones!

Feb 06, 2023

I was visiting my son and his lady when I developed steering and braking issues. Since I had a long drive back to North Carolina automotive problems were disconcerting at the very least. Tyler and Melissa more than highly recommended Gary's Auto Repair. They were spot on. Gary was covered up with work but was kind of enough to work me in. It took Gary very little time to discover the cause of my issues. All was taken care of expeditiously and professionally. I was very happy with the bill as well. I would highly recommend Gary's.

Feb 06, 2023

This guy better be good at what he does, because whoever answers the phone is extremely rude to potential customers.

Feb 06, 2022

A true mechanic - very knowledgeable and fair pricing. Honest. A person that should be included in the family as the go to person for car maintenance

Feb 06, 2022

I’m a young girl who doesn’t know much about vehicles. I’ve had the worst luck in mechanics. Gary is always upfront and honest always gives it to me straight. professional always kind and always has the best intentions for his customers. He treats me like family and has always made sure my vehicle is safe and taken care of thank y’all so much !

Feb 06, 2022

Real honest and genuine people. Definitely recommend this auto repair shop in Sarasota!

Feb 06, 2022

Very good experience I will go back there very reasonable very nice person and staff also told me what I would be needing in the future and prices everything was reasonable thank you so much

Feb 06, 2022

Very rude and unprofessional. Told me he would fix my car belt for 65 and changed his words telling me he never said that then he was like the price changes daily and asked me to go somewhere else I don’t recommend people like him who lies.

Feb 06, 2022

We've worked on all of our own beater cars for the last 15yrs. So when this car became to much for us, we had no idea how to find a good mechanic that would be fair and honest. Family recommended you but your many glowing google reviews made our decision. Gary's automotive deserves every 5 star rating they've earned. Everyone was friendly, knowledgeable, helpful and completely professional at all times even though I'm sure you were frustrated as well. Thank you for being patient and explaining everything multiple times to multiple people. We knew when we bought this Jeep that the seller didn't maintain it properly. But after fixing and installing so many parts on our own and still having problems, I was tired and frustrated. We didn't expect the car to need so much work but we're grateful you put in the time and effort to check and fix every part to get our car running properly and safely. Thank you for being honest, fairly priced, and working as quickly as possible. You guys went above and beyond with your services for us and gave us a break in a time of need and that's so rare and so appreciated. If you're willing to have us back we would like to stay with you for our future repairs and recommend you to anyone else needing your services.

Feb 06, 2021

Best place to repair your car ! Always very satisfied with their work! So happy to met very trustful mechanic! Finally my car is always in a good hands and prices are very good also !!!

Feb 06, 2021

Gary is wonderful! He is very honest, doesn’t try to sell you on repairs that you don’t absolutely need. I have 3 kids that I’m always driving around so I need to be safe. Also being a single mom I am on a tight budget so being able to get the safety issues repaired at a fair price is very important to me. Other shops have tried to tell me things were wrong with my car that really weren’t because they just wanted to make money off me and think because I am a woman I won’t know the difference. Marie & her daughter Michelle in the office are so nice as well. Overall it was a very great experience and I highly recommend them for all your car repair needs!!

Feb 06, 2021

Gary's is fantastic,he's the best mechanic I've seen around this area and very fair on his prices.very experienced..

Feb 06, 2021

I found a brochure for this service in my mailbox. When I called the indicated phone number, a man answered me. He was very rude and unfriendly. I will not deal with those who do not know how to be polite on the phone!

Feb 06, 2021

I have always found this business to be top notch in every aspect. Gary is beyond a Master Mechanic. I still can't figure out how he can diagnosis my car's problem by the way I tell him it sounds. He's been right every time. I've been here in Florida for 8 years now and I highly recommend Gary's Auto Repair Service, Inc. Prices are reasonable.

Feb 06, 2021

I own a 66 Mustang. After doing my whole front end in my driveway , it went to two garages and two places for allignment to get it straight. None could do it. I was told i needed anything from new upper arms to a spanner bar , to frame machine and even being told it CAN'T be aligned. After a few hours of work , i got the call. "Cars done" After 5 months of fighting pulling and diving , Gary got her straight. Finally got to hear her transmission kick in to third gear for the first time in months, since i couldn't go over 40mph without it diving. I cannot say thank you enough for getting me my old girl back on the road.

Feb 06, 2021

Went there to get a guesstimate on some repair work, Now have an appt, to get the work done. Thanks